Sunday Monitor

Policy writing or political writing: Does it matter?

A popular definition of policy writing states that it is a process to create clear and structured policy documents, which help a government or institution by providing solutions to specific problems. On the contrary, political writing is defined as influencing support, mobilising support or explaining issues related to policymaking.

If the above is to be considered, then both do matter. Policy writing focuses on clarity, neutrality, feasibility and consistency, and political writing stresses being persuasive and is guided by a particular aspect or objective.

Advertisement

In other words, when one thinks of policy writing, it means: Problem->data->solutions->measuring the success. When it comes to political writing, it simply means: Does it matter?->What is the challenge?->Who is the owner?->How to build a roadmap to address the challenges?

To further understand the above, it is important to know the differences, and they are:

Description Policy Writing Political Writing
Objective Provide clear, evidence-based guidance or solutions Persuades, influences opinions and advocates
Tone Formal Persuasive and argumentative
Audience Administrators, policy makers and implementers General public and community
Composition Structured Unstructured
Use of evidence Data and research Selective use of information
Expected Outcome Policy change Political opinion
Style of writing Simple, straightforward and minimum use of technical terminologies Impactful

Elements

Policy Writing

Ensure that information conveyed to policymakers is actionable and easy to understand by using simple language and avoiding jargon.

  • Use evidence to back information and help frame problems
  • Define problems clearly backed by strong evidence and analysis

Political Writing

  • Develop strong narratives to help translate the concerns of the public into policy decisions
  • Cater to specific stakeholders

In general, both should:

  • Write effective narratives with clear and doable action points, roles and responsibilities and expected outcomes
  • Identify clear metrics for measuring impact and outcomes
  • Be accurate and avoid the use of incorrect information

Advantages of Policy Writing

  • Helps governments and institutions to make informed decisions by using data and effective research analysis
  • Provides clarity through a structured approach to include roles and responsibilities
  • Shapes institutions and governance on a long-term basis
  • Encourages a cross-sectoral approach by providing frameworks to help different departments
  • Ensures that recommendations are actionable and can be implemented with minimal hitches

Challenges in Policy Writing

  • Political resistance due to recommendations
  • Misunderstanding information due to technical jargon and the use of complex language
  • Resource constraints and lack of knowledge during implementation
  • Different understanding and priorities of stakeholders
  • Lack of appropriate personnel to include data analysts and researchers, to name a few

Advantages of Political Writing

  • Accessibility is simple and easy due to the language used to communicate facts
  • Persuasive and hence can mobilise and draw the attention of people and stakeholders
  • Attracts people’s involvement due to the human approach to issues
  • Can be shared on a wide and several fora to include debates, social media posts, op-eds, and campaigns, to name a few

Challenges in Political Writing

  • Distorted information can affect accuracy
  • Becomes redundant if not addressed immediately
  • High propaganda ad persuasiveness can lead to people losing interest
  • Simplification of information may not convey the right information

Scenario for Policy Writing

Problem Statement: Bengaluru faces a severe traffic congestion, which has affected liveability, travel, quality of the environment, to name a few. According to a report in 2025, there are over 1.2 crore registered vehicles, and registration of private cars exceeds 23 lakhs, the highest in India. In general, commuters lose around 132 hours annually due to traffic jams.

Objectives of a Policy:

  • Enact traffic laws more effectively by regulating movement of vehicles
  • Attempt to improve travel speeds and reduce congestion
  • Improve and upgrade mobility infrastructure

Policy Recommendations

  • Reduce on-street parking and introduce costs for parking
  • Improve the quality of roads and ensure that designated corridors for public and private vehicles are introduced and followed strictly
  • Introduce more metro services with appropriate last-mile facilities
  • Encourage flexible travel hours by demarcating educational institutions, private and public offices, etc.

Expected Outcomes

  • Reduction of dependency on private vehicles and increased use of public transport
  • Decline in commute times and congestion levels
  • Alignment of sustainable and resilient mobility ecosystem
Scenario for Political Writing

Problem Statement:

For a long time, India’s climate action has remained cocooned in conferences and committees. Being an agrarian country, Indian farmers are facing the brunt of climate change. It has been estimated that farmers lost an estimated Rs 25,000 crore due to damage to crop yield.

Objectives:

  • Align climate action with jobs and welfare
  • Be transparent and accountable for issues related to climate-related decisions to build trust with people
  • Position climate resilience as the topmost need in political manifestos

Recommendations:

  • Track government progress by developing a dashboard for political accountability
  • Create employment opportunities for rural youth to include climate field officers, technicians, and irrigation auditors, to name a few
  • Build resilient infrastructure in rural areas to include effective water systems for irrigation and seed banks

Expected Outcomes

  • Reduction of migration issues to regain economic stability in rural areas
  • Increase in job opportunities for rural youth in areas related to an agrarian economy
  • Build a safe, resilient rural economy to safeguard from droughts and floods

It does not matter if it is policy writing or political writing. What is important is that the content should impress people who matter and become a tool for change. It should be persuasive for an actionable change from a policymaking angle, from an acceptance angle from communities and make a great impact.

Related Articles

Back to top button
error: Content is protected !!
Close

Adblock Detected

Kindly Disable Ad Blocker